Searchbar in Firefox
posted on 2009-09-14
Introduction
One of the hot topics of the last years is usability. Consistency can help improving the usability, but I think Firefox 3 fails in consistency when you use the searchbar on three different operation systems: Linux, Windows and Mac OSX.
Example 1: Windows
On Windows shows the searchbar like this:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/721ed/721edb3e7d9604c5f8eee5b95c4df2dd7d1b1c72" alt="ff-searchbox-windows.png"
I really like this layout. You can argue about the position of the buttons: “Next” on the right seems to make more sense, while “Next” on the left will make it easier to push it.
Example 2: Linux
Next image shows how the searchbar looks on Linux (OpenSUSE 11 with KDE3 in my case).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f44f3/f44f3ce4fbeba1493356a4d88952bd13ca4115eb" alt="ff-searchbox-linux.png"
This layout is quite good. The icons are really clear what the buttons do and the position of the buttons makes sense.
Example 3: Mac OSX
On Mac OSX 10.5 the seachbar looks like this:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/91801/918016db3388e29e0858fc27b46ddf0aa34941ed" alt="ff-searchbox-mac.png"
In my opinion, this layout stinks. The position of the buttons is incorrect, because the button shape makes the “Previous” button look like “Next” and vice versa.
Conclusion
I know there are limit on these different OS’s about what you can do with the default UI elements (for example on Mac OSX). But I think the people at Mozilla should try harder to make the user clear what the buttons do and at least change which the position of the two buttons.